I had it all figured out. I was absolutely certain how Vintage Sparkle should come together. Last Friday I finished assembling the center and thought the borders would be added by the end of the weekend. The top was almost done!
At that point I started wavering about my plan for the borders. I have since come up with many competing plans. That has proved rather paralyzing. What If I start on plan B but then decide plan A was the better option after all? Or maybe plan C? And if I had thought of plan B in the first place I would have constructed the edges of the quilt differently to make plan B easier and reduce clunky seams. Maybe I should unpick what I’ve done to allow for that? But do I have enough fabric to allow for that alternate construction?
Today I draped the quilt top over my bed and mocked up 3 options on a bit of the edge.
The star that bites into the border in B and C repeats the cornerstone stars from the rest of the quilt. I like that extra element, but A is certainly simpler at this point. If I choose B or C, I’ll then have to decide how to accomplish that as an afterthought. I know exactly how I would do it if I had planned it from the start! I suppose I could unsew the rows and sashing and proceed that way but…I hated pinning and sewing those long seams and I suspect I wouldn’t enjoy unpicking and then doing them over!
Okay, I’m done with the whining. Maybe I’ll just let this one sit awhile while I go work on the tax return. Not that that is much more fun!
Linking up with Linky Tuesday at Freemotion by the River
I just hate it when I do things like this to myself! The bottom line is this quilt is beautiful! Any one of those choices would be the right one. . . that didn't help you much did it? ;)ReplyDelete
A very pretty quilt and you can't go wrong with any of the border ideas you have. But I know what you mean, it's like beating ourselves up over the decision!ReplyDelete
Either way it is going to look great.ReplyDelete
I know that feeling, sometimes it is good to walk away for a bit. I think they all look good but I do like the B the best. Haven't even started the taxes but that should happen this next weekend.ReplyDelete
Whatever you choose will be beautiful, ripping out is never any fun. We finished out taxes last week.....not fun but done! Thanks for sharing.ReplyDelete
Freemotion by the River Linky Party Tuesday
They're all pretty, but I think A calls to me most. I like how the gold "finishes" the quilt and then the prairie points are a bonus on the edges. But I also like C where the stars formed in the sashings get a finish. No matter which you choose, it's going to be a wonderful quilt!ReplyDelete
I could live easily with Plan A! Even if it is not your favorite, just think how much time you would save to work on a new quilt if you didn't have to do all that ripping! Good decision to think on it a bit; then whatever you choose will be the best for you. You can't go wrong with any of the three! ---"LoveReplyDelete
I think A looks great with the gold, but agree with others seeing the stars in B is lovely too. I also really like your heading for your blog - it's rainbows everywhere!ReplyDelete
They all look good, very pretty, I'd choose the least amount of ripping, good luck with it all!!ReplyDelete
My favorites are A and C. I love the way the gold frames everything in A, but I also like the completed stars in C. I would do what will make you the most happy in the long run. They all look beautiful with how it hangs on the bed.ReplyDelete
I love plan C but they all are beautiful and after it's done no one will know which was which so you must please yourself.ReplyDelete
I have to say B is my favourite (I love the finished stars). If it was me I wouldn't even consider all that ripping! I'd either find a way around it or go with a different idea.ReplyDelete
Letting is simmer a while is usually a good idea. The answer will come to you while you are doing something else. I really like plan C, but they are all good, so you can't go wrong!ReplyDelete
It is much better to walk away and take a break before making your final decision instead of rushing in and doing something just to get it finished. All of your options look great!ReplyDelete
I love the layout for B..... but since I don't like taking things apart (especially long things to sew) I'd go with the easiest solution. I could easily see version B in blue,cream and gold =).ReplyDelete
Good luck with your decision.
I like plan C but it is your decision. I like the stars dipping down and the red border. It is a very pretty quilt, letting it sit a little will help you make the best choice. I love the colors, they look so warm and inviting.ReplyDelete
Well plan A looks beautiful and I sure do think the quilt is amazing with any of the options. Of course I would not unsew all those seams soooo.ReplyDelete
It will be fantastic whichever one you choose in the end.
I will be very unhelpful and say that any of those Plans would be lovely - I just love the actual quilt so much! Just wonderful colour combinations. Looking forward to seeing how you do actually finish it now! xCathy (ps Giveaway at mine!?)ReplyDelete
I know I would choose A because it's the most straight forward but B is nice with the stars going into the border. However, nothing could be so bad as to prefer doing your tax return, eek!!ReplyDelete
I like Plan C. Not sure if my comment is now after the fact, but I know you're pulling this baby back out right away... LOVE the stars biting into the border.ReplyDelete